← Back to the chapter · Previous detail · Next detail →

Technical detail · Compute Offloading and Placement

The radio does not stop with the packet

15.7 The Radio Does Not Stop When The Packet Does

A naive offload model counts only the active transmit time. Real radios add two costs that can flip a break-even. First, connection setup: bringing up a BLE connection or attaching a cellular modem burns energy before any payload moves, which punishes small transfers most. Second, the tail: after the last byte, many radios hold a high-power state for a while before releasing. A cellular modem in particular can stay connected for several seconds after transmission, drawing tens of milliamps, before it drops to a low-power idle or power-save mode. That tail is pure overhead a payload-only calculation misses.

The energy-per-bit also varies enormously by technology, so the break-even data size is radio-specific. A short-range link like BLE moves bits cheaply. A long-range low-rate link like LoRa has such low throughput that a modest payload occupies the radio for a long airtime, making its energy per bit high. A cellular link adds the setup and tail costs above. The same 30 KB break-even computed for BLE could be a few kilobytes on a slow or tail-heavy radio.

Worked example: suppose a small cellular offload transmits for 0.4 s at 120 mA, so a payload-only model records only 48 mA-s. The modem also spends 25 mA-s attaching and then holds a 40 mA connected tail for 8 s, adding 320 mA-s. The real radio charge is 25 + 48 + 320 = 393 mA-s. If the local compute path is 90 mA-s, the payload-only model says offload wins, while the measured device says local compute is more than four times cheaper. That is why tail timers and network state must be captured with the same power trace as payload transfer.

Waiting also costs current if the link stays up while the server computes, even though no payload is moving. BLE, LoRa, and cellular can differ by orders of magnitude in per-bit cost; recompute the boundary for the actual radio.

← Back to the chapter · Previous detail · Next detail →