Build an IoT Business Case

Build an IoT Business Case

animation
iot
applications

Build an IoT Business Case

Scenario: Your city (population 250,000) wants to deploy a smart parking system across downtown (800 parking spaces in 12 multi-level garages). For the city parking scenario, assume availability data saves 8 minutes of circling per parker.

Given Data:

  • Parking space sensors: $125 each
  • Gateway hubs (1 per garage): $2,400 each
  • Installation labor: $45 per sensor
  • Cellular connectivity: $8/month per gateway
  • Cloud platform: $15,000/year
  • Maintenance (sensor replacement): 12% annual failure rate
  • Average daily parkers: 2,400 (workdays), 1,800 (weekends)
  • Driver hourly value: $27
  • Fuel cost savings: $0.85 per avoided circling event
  • Annual operating days: 260 workdays + 105 weekend days

Your Task (Step-by-Step):

  1. Calculate CapEx:
    • Sensors: _________ x $125 = $_________
    • Gateways: _________ x $2,400 = $_________
    • Installation: _________ x $45 = $_________
    • Total CapEx: $_________
  2. Calculate Annual OpEx:
    • Connectivity: _________ x $8 x 12 = $_________/year
    • Cloud platform: $_________/year
    • Sensor replacement: _________ x 12% x $125 = $_________/year
    • Total OpEx: $_________/year
  3. Calculate Annual Time Savings:
    • Workday savings: _________ parkers x 8 min x 260 days / 60 = _________ hours
    • Weekend savings: _________ parkers x 8 min x 105 days / 60 = _________ hours
    • Total annual hours saved: _________
    • Dollar value: _________ x $27 = $_________
  4. Calculate Fuel Savings:
    • Annual parking events: (_________ x 260) + (_________ x 105) = _________
    • Fuel savings: _________ x $0.85 = $_________
  5. Compute ROI:
    • Total annual benefit: Time + Fuel = $_________
    • Net annual benefit: $_________ - $_________ (OpEx) = $_________
    • Payback period: $_________ (CapEx) / $_________ = _________ years

What to Observe:

  • Is your payback period under 3 years? (Typical threshold for municipal projects)
  • What percentage of total 5-year costs is OpEx vs. CapEx?
  • If the city only deployed sensors in 6 of 12 garages (50% coverage), how would that affect the benefit calculation?

Solution

  1. CapEx:
    • Sensors: 800 x $125 = $100,000
    • Gateways: 12 x $2,400 = $28,800
    • Installation: 800 x $45 = $36,000
    • Total CapEx: $164,800
  2. Annual OpEx:
    • Connectivity: 12 x $8 x 12 = $1,152/year
    • Cloud platform: $15,000/year
    • Sensor replacement: 800 x 12% x $125 = $12,000/year
    • Total OpEx: $28,152/year
  3. Annual Time Savings:
    • Workday savings: 2,400 x 8/60 x 260 = 83,200 hours
    • Weekend savings: 1,800 x 8/60 x 105 = 25,200 hours
    • Total: 108,400 hours
    • Dollar value: 108,400 x $27 = $2,926,800
  4. Fuel Savings:
    • Annual events: (2,400 x 260) + (1,800 x 105) = 813,000
    • Fuel savings: 813,000 x $0.85 = $691,050
  5. ROI:
    • Total benefit: $2,926,800 + $691,050 = $3,617,850
    • Net benefit: $3,617,850 - $28,152 = $3,589,698
    • Payback period: $164,800 / $3,589,698 = 0.046 years = 17 days

Key Insights:

  • Smart parking has extreme ROI because it addresses a daily pain point for thousands of people For this parking scenario, annual OpEx is about 17% of CapEx.
  • 5-year TCO: $164,800 + ($28,152 x 5) = $305,560, vs. State this as a modeled gross benefit-to-cost multiple of about 59× using the scenario’s $18.089M benefits and $305,560 five-year TCO; actual ROI also subtracts costs and requires adoption assumptions.

Back to the chapter