Exercise: Calculate Parking Sensor ROI
Exercise: Calculate Parking Sensor ROI
animation
applications
smart-cities
Exercise: Calculate Parking Sensor ROI
You have now seen the city-wide business case and the lighting-specific payback. This exercise narrows the numbers back to one parking service so you can check whether the same assumptions still work at a smaller scale.
Challenge: A city has 8,000 on-street parking spaces downtown. Drivers currently search an average of 14 minutes per trip for parking. The city wants to deploy smart parking sensors.
Your task: Calculate the annual savings and ROI.
Given:
- Sensor cost: $185 per space (hardware + installation)
- Connectivity: $2 per sensor per month (LoRaWAN or NB-IoT)
- Platform: $40,000 per year (cloud software license)
- Current parking search time: 14 minutes per trip
- Target search time with sensors: 4 minutes per trip
- Average parking turnover: 4 times per space per day
- Fuel cost: $3.50 per gallon
- Average vehicle: 25 MPG city driving, 1 mile per 5 minutes of driving
- Average driver hourly value: $15
Solution:
- Capital cost: 8,000 sensors × $185 = $1,480,000
- Annual operations: (8,000 × $2 × 12) + $40,000 = $232,000
- Time saved per parking event: 14 min - 4 min = 10 minutes
- Annual parking events: 8,000 spaces × 4 per day × 365 = 11,680,000
- Driver time value: 11,680,000 × (10/60 hours) × $15 = $29,200,000 per year
- Fuel saved: 11,680,000 × (10/5 miles) × (1/25 gal) × $3.50 = $3,270,400 per year
- Total annual benefit: $29.2M + $3.27M = $32,470,000
- ROI: ($32.47M - $0.232M) / $1.48M = 2,178% (payback in 17 days)
Key insight: In this model, time savings dwarf fuel savings (9:1 ratio). Adoption is a sensitivity input, not a consequence that can be calculated from coverage alone; test it with an honestly bounded pilot.