Design a Fall Alert Cascade
Design a Fall Alert Cascade
Checkpoint: Latency Budget
You know:
- The 15-minute response requirement becomes 420 seconds after subtracting the 8-minute EMS response assumption.
- The chapter’s detection and notification chain is 5.1 seconds plus 2.1 seconds, leaving 412.8 seconds, or 6.9 minutes, for graduated caregiver response.
- The T+0, T+30s, T+3min, and T+5min cascade is a clinical budget expressed as product behavior.
Design a Fall Alert Cascade
Activity: Design a multi-tier alert cascade for a home fall detection system serving elderly patients.
Time: 20 minutes | Difficulty: Intermediate
Scenario: You’re designing alerts for a wearable fall detector. When a fall is detected, the system must balance rapid response with avoiding false alarm fatigue.
Your task: Fill in the blanks in this alert cascade design.
- T+0 seconds: Fall detected by accelerometer (>3g impact) + gyroscope (>90° rotation). What should happen first?
- T+30 seconds: Patient hasn’t pressed “I’m OK”. Next action?
- T+3 minutes: Primary contact hasn’t acknowledged. Next escalation?
- T+5 minutes: Still no human response. Final action?
Hint
Work backwards from the exercise’s 15-minute response target. Subtracting the assumed 8-minute EMS journey leaves 7 minutes for detection, notification and escalation. Detection and notification consume part of that allowance, so the remaining time must accommodate both patient cancellation and caregiver response.
Give the patient 30 seconds to cancel, then notify the primary caregiver. If there is no acknowledgement, contact the secondary caregiver at three minutes and dispatch emergency services at five minutes. With the assumed EMS journey, that dispatch time places arrival at thirteen minutes, leaving two minutes for uncertainty. Treat these timings as planning assumptions to test. Review whether cancellation filters false alerts and whether caregivers acknowledge promptly, while recording each transition so delays and unresolved alerts can be examined.
Solution
Optimal cascade:
- T+0: Patient given 30 seconds to press “I’m OK” button (allows patient to self-cancel false alarms)
- T+30 sec: Alert primary caregiver via push notification + SMS (family member likely closest and fastest response)
- T+3 min: Alert secondary caregiver if primary doesn’t acknowledge (backup family member)
- T+5 min: Automatic 911 dispatch with GPS coordinates and patient medical history
Why this works:
- Workflow assumption to test in a pilot: wearer self-cancellation filters about 50% of false positives (such as sitting down hard or dropping the device).
- Workflow assumption to test in a pilot: primary caregiver response takes 2–3 minutes and handles about 40% of real falls.
- The fraction of true falls escalated to EMS is unknown until wearer cancellation and caregiver response are measured among confirmed falls.
- On the EMS branch, dispatch at T+5 plus an assumed 8-minute arrival gives T+13, leaving 2 minutes of the 15-minute target for uncertainty.
Design principle: Give increasing authority at each tier - patient has ultimate control, then family, then medical professionals. This prevents both “boy who cried wolf” abandonment AND missed critical events.