← Back to the chapter · Previous detail · Next detail →
Technical detail · Edge Acquisition: Missing Data and Field Design
GPS collar with a registered cellular modem
The Flawed Calculation:
| Activity | Duration/Hour | Current | Energy/Hour |
|---|---|---|---|
| GPS fix acquisition | 60 seconds | 40 mA | 0.667 mAh |
| Sleep | 3540 seconds | 0.05 mA | 0.050 mAh |
| Total | - | - | 0.717 mAh/hour |
Expected life: 3400 mAh ÷ 0.717 mAh/hour = 4741 hours = 6.6 months
What Was Forgotten - Cellular Transmission:
This GPS collar sends location to the cloud over cellular (2G/3G/4G). Its assumed modem characteristics are:
- Idle (registered to network): 5 mA
- Transmitting (GPRS/3G): 200-400 mA peak, 150 mA average
- Transmission time: 5-10 seconds per GPS report (TCP handshake + HTTP POST + response)
Revised Calculation:
| Activity | Duration/Hour | Current | Energy/Hour |
|---|---|---|---|
| GPS fix | 60 seconds | 40 mA | 0.667 mAh |
| Cellular TX (10 sec) | 10 seconds | 200 mA | 0.556 mAh |
| Cellular idle | 3530 seconds | 5 mA | 4.903 mAh |
| Sleep (GPS/cellular off) | 0 seconds | - | 0 mAh |
| Total | - | - | 6.126 mAh/hour |
Battery life predicted by this budget: 3400 mAh ÷ 6.126 mAh/hour = 555 hours = 23 days; this does not match the stated three-month field life, so the measured modem duty cycle or field-life premise needs reconciliation.
Cellular operation dominates this budget:
- GPS: 0.667 mAh (11% of total)
- Cellular: 5.459 mAh (89% of total!)