← Back to the chapter · Previous detail · Next detail →
Technical detail · Edge Acquisition: Missing Data and Field Design
Collar batching and low-power radio comparison
Correct Design - Reduce Transmission:
Option 1 - Batch Transmissions:
- Collect 24 GPS fixes in local flash memory
- Transmit once per day (1 longer transmission vs 24 short ones)
- Cellular modem off 23 hours/day
| Activity | Duration/Day | Current | Energy/Day |
|---|---|---|---|
| GPS fix (24x) | 24 minutes | 40 mA | 16 mAh |
| Cellular TX (1x, 60s) | 60 seconds | 200 mA | 3.33 mAh |
| Sleep | 23.5 hours | 50 μA | 1.18 mAh |
| Total/day | - | - | 20.51 mAh |
New battery life: 3400 mAh ÷ 20.51 mAh/day = 166 days = 5.5 months (still short)
Option 2 - Compare a LoRaWAN Radio:
- LoRaWAN transmission: 120 mA for 2 seconds (vs 200 mA for 10 seconds cellular)
- No idle current (radio off between transmissions)
- Energy: 120 mA × 2s ÷ 3600 = 0.067 mAh per transmission
| Activity | Duration/Hour | Current | Energy/Hour |
|---|---|---|---|
| GPS fix | 60 seconds | 40 mA | 0.667 mAh |
| LoRaWAN TX | 2 seconds | 120 mA | 0.067 mAh |
| Sleep | 3538 seconds | 50 μA | 0.050 mAh |
| Total | - | - | 0.784 mAh/hour |
The sleep duration is 3,538 seconds after the 60-second fix and 2-second burst; rounded charge totals remain unchanged.
New battery life: 3400 mAh ÷ 0.784 mAh/hour = 4337 hours = 6.0 months (still needs work)