← Back to the chapter

Technical detail · Data Preprocessing Workflow

Under the Hood: audit the HVAC cost estimate

Quantifying the 1-10-100 Rule for IoT Data Quality

Use this arithmetic when reviewing the cost assumptions behind a prevention decision.

The classic 1-10-100 quality-cost rule of thumb illustrates $1 to prevent, $10 to correct, and $100 when a problem causes failure. ASQ

Example: Smart HVAC with stuck sensor reading 15°C in summer

Prevention Cost ($1 equivalent - timestamp staleness check):

CPU Cost=1 comparison/reading×10−6 seconds×$0.0013600 seconds\text{CPU Cost} = 1 \text{ comparison/reading} \times 10^{-6} \text{ seconds} \times \frac{\$0.001}{3600 \text{ seconds}} ≈2.8×10−13 per reading≈$0 (negligible)\approx 2.8 \times 10^{-13} \text{ per reading} \approx \$0 \text{ (negligible)}

Correction Cost ($10 equivalent - retrospective data repair):

Storage Scan=86,400 readings/day×30 days×10−4 s/scan\text{Storage Scan} = 86,400 \text{ readings/day} \times 30 \text{ days} \times 10^{-4} \text{ s/scan} =259 seconds compute=$0.07 cloud compute= 259 \text{ seconds compute} = \$0.07 \text{ cloud compute} +Engineer Time=2 hours×$100/hour=$200{}+ \text{Engineer Time} = 2 \text{ hours} \times \$100/\text{hour} = \$200

Failure Cost ($100 equivalent - heater ran 8 hours unnecessarily):

Energy Waste=5 kW×8 hours×$0.12/kWh=$4.80/day\text{Energy Waste} = 5 \text{ kW} \times 8 \text{ hours} \times \$0.12/\text{kWh} = \$4.80/\text{day} ×30 days before detected=$144\times 30 \text{ days before detected} = \$144 Total Failure Cost=$144+$200 (investigation)=$344\text{Total Failure Cost} = \$144 + \$200 \text{ (investigation)} = \$344

Actual Ratio:

CorrectionPrevention=$200$0=undefinedFailurePrevention=$344$0=undefined\frac{\text{Correction}}{\text{Prevention}} = \frac{\$200}{\$0} = \text{undefined} \quad \frac{\text{Failure}}{\text{Prevention}} = \frac{\$344}{\$0} = \text{undefined}

The prevention step is inexpensive in this example, but a ratio requires a nonzero, consistently measured prevention cost; choose edge validation based on the measured cost and risk of failures.

← Back to the chapter