Check: Adoption, cost, and the pump proposal

Knowledge check · self-test
Check: Adoption, cost, and the pump proposal
Review the original knowledge checks.
Review the original knowledge checks.
Checkpoint: Cost Trajectory {.depth-l0}
- You now know why the chapter treats cost decline as important but not sufficient for adoption.
- You can compare the BLE, LoRaWAN, and cellular IoT examples without assuming every barrier falls at the same rate as hardware.
- You can ask what becomes viable at 10x cheaper while still naming security review, support, privacy, installation, and operations.
:::
## Learning from History {.depth-l1}
**Scenario:** Your company manufactures traditional industrial pumps. A junior engineer proposes adding IoT sensors to monitor vibration, temperature, and flow rate. The VP of Sales dismisses the idea: "Our customers want reliable pumps, not gadgets. They've never asked for this."
**Questions to Consider:**
1. **Which historical pattern does the VP's response mirror?**
- *Answer*: This mirrors both "We have messenger boys" (evaluating new technology by old paradigm standards) and "No customer asked for a mobile phone" (customers don't ask for paradigm shifts). The VP is anchored to existing customer behavior.
2. **What new use cases might emerge that aren't obvious today?**
- *Answer*: Predictive maintenance (pump signals failure before it happens), usage-based billing (pay per gallon pumped), performance optimization (adjust pump settings based on conditions), fleet management (monitor hundreds of pumps remotely), warranty validation (prove operating conditions were within spec), energy optimization (pumps account for 20% of industrial electricity).
3. **What would happen if a competitor added these sensors first?**
- *Answer*: They could offer predictive maintenance contracts, reduce customer downtime by 25-40%, build data moats that enable continuous improvement, and potentially shift from selling pumps to selling "pumping-as-a-service" -- a recurring revenue model worth 3-5x the pump sale price.
4. **How might you reframe the proposal to address the VP's concerns?**
- *Answer*: Frame IoT not as a "gadget" but as a reliability enhancement -- the sensors don't replace pump quality, they protect the customer's investment by predicting failures and optimizing performance. Start with a pilot program to generate data on actual benefits. Emphasize competitive threat: "If we don't offer this, our competitors will."
**The History Lesson Applied:** AT&T's landline expertise made them dismiss mobile. Your pump expertise could make you dismiss IoT. The question isn't whether your current customers are asking for IoT -- it's whether your future customers (or your competitors' customers) will expect it.
Back to IoT History: Adoption and Cost: Follow the Smart Watch's Changing Value