Applications & Use Cases · Study deck

IoT History: Adoption and Cost

A useful device can stay niche until cost, trust, and supporting networks cross a threshold.

Blueprint Bina is your guide for this deck.

history
Blueprint Bina, the module guide, in a scene from this chapter.
iotclass.org

After studying this chapter

Learning objectives

You will be able to:

  • Explain: This reading constrains iot segments sit at different points on the adoption curve; integration, policy, and trust can slow even cheap technologies and supplies the visual evidence for the iot adoption s-curve.
  • Explain: Phase 2: Apple Watch Launch and Skepticism (2015): Even after Apple entered the market, critics focused on what smart watches did worse than existing products rather than what they uniquely enabled.
  • Explain: IoT parallel: Smart meters were deployed for billing accuracy, then became grid optimization tools, then enabled demand-response programs worth billions.
  • Explain: IoT is enabling predictive maintenance, precision agriculture, remote healthcare.
iotclass.org

Major section

The Anatomy of Paradigm Blindness

Anchoring to Existing Behavior: Forecasters assume people will continue behaving as they currently do.

  • McKinsey asked "Who among current telephone users would pay $4,000 for a worse phone?" instead of asking "What would 100 million NEW users do with portable communication?".
  • Linear Extrapolation of Exponential Change: Technology costs drop exponentially (Moore's Law), but human minds think linearly.
  • The revenue shift is a useful warning for IoT forecasts.

Why it matters

Similarly, IoT critics measure a "smart light bulb" against a regular light bulb's ability to produce light, missing everything else it enables.

iotclass.org

Major section

Historical Lesson Pitfalls

Learning from history is essential, but misapplying these lessons can be just as dangerous as ignoring them.

  • Pitfall 1: "Everything is the next telephone" fallacy.: Not every new technology is a paradigm shift.
  • Some IoT products genuinely are solutions looking for a problem.
  • Acknowledging these real challenges is not paradigm blindness; it is prudent engineering.

Why it matters

History shows that paradigm shifts change fundamental human behavior -- if a proposed IoT application does not enable a new behavior or solve a previously impossible problem, skepticism may be warranted.

iotclass.org

Major section

Innovator's Dilemma in IoT

Clayton Christensen's "Innovator's Dilemma" (1997) explains why successful companies fail to adopt disruptive technologies.

  • Expertise Becomes a Liability.
  • IoT parallel: Manufacturing companies optimized for product reliability may dismiss sensor data as "unnecessary complexity".
  • In 1983, no AT&T customer was asking for a mobile phone.
  • New Use Cases Emerge Unexpectedly.

Why it matters

IoT parallel: A $50 sensor on a $500 pump seems like a 10% cost increase for uncertain benefit -- until the sensor prevents a $50,000 production shutdown.

iotclass.org

Major section

Innovator's Dilemma in IoT (continued)

Incumbents correctly calculate that the new technology is inferior -- for existing use cases.

  • IoT is enabling predictive maintenance, precision agriculture, remote healthcare.
  • IoT parallel: Smart meters were deployed for billing accuracy, then became grid optimization tools, then enabled demand-response programs worth billions.
  • The Lesson for IoT Professionals:: When evaluating IoT applications, ask not "Does this solve existing problems better?" but rather "What new problems can this solve that were previously impossible?".
iotclass.org

Major section

The IoT Adoption S-Curve

Technology adoption follows a predictable S-curve pattern, but the timing and steepness of the curve are consistently underestimated.

  • This reading constrains iot segments sit at different points on the adoption curve; integration, policy, and trust can slow even cheap technologies and supplies the visual evidence for the iot adoption s-curve.
IoT segments sit at different points on the adoption curve; integration, policy, and trust can slow even cheap technologies.
IoT segments sit at different points on the adoption curve; integration, policy, and trust can slow even cheap technologies.
iotclass.org

Major section

Smart Watch Journey

Phase 3: The Unexpected Killer App (2018-2020): None of these use cases were in the original product pitch.

  • The smart watch story perfectly illustrates how paradigm blindness works -- and how it eventually gets overcome.
  • Swiss watch executives declared Apple Watch would not affect their market.
  • Hospitals integrate smart watch data into patient records.
iotclass.org

Major section

Smart Watch Journey (continued)

Phase 2: Apple Watch Launch and Skepticism (2015): Even after Apple entered the market, critics focused on what smart watches did worse than existing products rather than what they uniquely enabled.

  • They emerged from the combination of sensors + connectivity + processing that only a smart watch on a wrist could provide.
  • Phase 4: Essential Health Infrastructure (2022-2026): By 2026, smart watches have become medical devices.
  • It comes from enabling entirely new capabilities that were impossible before connectivity.
iotclass.org

Deck summary

Key takeaways

Anchoring to Existing Behavior: Forecasters assume people will continue behaving as they currently do.

  • Learning from history is essential, but misapplying these lessons can be just as dangerous as ignoring them.
  • Clayton Christensen's "Innovator's Dilemma" (1997) explains why successful companies fail to adopt disruptive technologies.
  • Incumbents correctly calculate that the new technology is inferior -- for existing use cases.
  • Technology adoption follows a predictable S-curve pattern, but the timing and steepness of the curve are consistently underestimated.
iotclass.org

Retrieval practice

Recall check 1 of 2

Blueprint Bina says: answer from memory, then check your reasoning.

Q1A widely reported 1980s forecast put the year-2000 mobile market at 900,000 units, while ITU recorded 738 million subscriptions. What best explains this roughly 820x actual-to-forecast ratio?

AMcKinsey used outdated cost curves and handset capability data in the forecast
BThey sized mobile demand from landline habits and missed texting, mobile internet, and apps
CMobile phone technology improved faster than analysts could project from semiconductor trends
DMcKinsey deliberately understated demand to protect AT&T's landline business case
Show answer

Answer: B Correct!

iotclass.org

Retrieval practice

Recall check 2 of 2

Blueprint Bina says: answer from memory, then check your reasoning.

Q2A startup proposes putting IoT sensors in all concrete structures to monitor curing and structural health. A construction industry veteran dismisses it: 'Concrete has been fine for 2,000 years without sensors. This is a solution looking for a problem.' Which historical parallel BEST describes this response?

AThe veteran is making a sound business judgment based on industry experience
BThis mirrors 'We have messenger boys'
CThe veteran is correct because concrete structures genuinely don't benefit from monitoring
DThe startup should abandon the idea because the market isn't ready
Show answer

Answer: B Correct!

iotclass.org

Print reference

Answers

Answer key.

  1. B · Correct!
  2. B · Correct!
iotclass.org