URLLC Warehouse Design

URLLC Warehouse Design

animation
cellular-iot
urllc

Try It Yourself

WarningHands-On Challenge

Task: Design URLLC connectivity for an autonomous vehicle warehouse operation.

Scenario: 100 AGVs (automated guided vehicles) navigate a 500,000 m2 warehouse at speeds up to 2 m/s. Collision avoidance requires stopping within 0.5 meters upon obstacle detection.

Calculate Latency Budget:

  • Stopping distance: 0.5 meters at 2 m/s = _____ ms travel time.
  • Sensor processing: Object detection via LiDAR = 10 ms.
  • Braking actuation: Pneumatic brake engagement = 50 ms.
  • Network budget: 250 ms total - 10 ms (sensor) - 50 ms (brake) = _____ ms.

Is URLLC Necessary?

Start by Standard 5G eMBB latency: 10-50 ms class -> _____ (meets/exceeds) budget? Then Engineered URLLC/private edge latency: low single-digit ms class -> _____ (meets/exceeds) budget? Finally What happens if network latency spikes to 100 ms during handover? AGV travels _____ meters before stopping.

Cost-Benefit Analysis:

Start by Public 5G eMBB: $30/AGV/month x 100 = $3,000/month ($180,000 over 5 years). Then Private 5G URLLC: $500,000 upfront + $40,000/year OpEx = $700,000 over 5 years. Next Single AGV collision damage: Estimated $150,000 (damaged goods + downtime). After that eMBB collision probability assumption: 2% per AGV-year (latency spikes during peak hours). Finally Private edge collision probability assumption: 0.01% per AGV-year after validation.

Expected Loss Calculation:

Start by eMBB: 100 AGVs x 2% x $150,000 x 5 years = $_____. Then Private edge: 100 AGVs x 0.01% x $150,000 x 5 years = $_____. Finally Net savings with URLLC: (eMBB loss) - (URLLC loss) - (URLLC premium) = $_____.

Your Recommendation: Based on 5-year TCO including expected collision costs, should the warehouse deploy: Start by [ ] Public 5G eMBB (lower upfront, higher risk). Then [ ] Private 5G URLLC (higher upfront, lower risk). Finally [ ] Wired Ethernet for AGVs (predictable low link latency where a tether is practical, but limited mobility).

Reflection:

Start by At what AGV count does private URLLC become economically justified purely on collision avoidance? Finally If AGV speed increases to 5 m/s, does the latency budget change your recommendation?

Back to the chapter