Detect Paradigm Blindness

Detect Paradigm Blindness

animation
iot
applications

Detect Paradigm Blindness

Time: 45 minutes | Difficulty: Intermediate | Challenge: Apply the SHIFT framework to an IoT proposal in your environment

Scenario: Identify ONE IoT application in your industry or organization that leadership has dismissed as “unnecessary” or “too expensive.” Use the SHIFT framework to reframe the proposal.

Your Task:

  1. Document the Dismissal (5 minutes):

    • What was the IoT proposal? (sensors in X, connected Y, automated Z)
    • What objection did leadership raise? (customers don’t ask for it, too expensive, not our core business, etc.)
    • Which historical parallel does this match? (messenger boys, mobile phones, smart watches)
  2. Apply SHIFT Framework (30 minutes):

    Letter Question Your Analysis
    S - Second-order effects What happens AFTER the first use case? (Fill in)
    H - Human behavior change How might people behave differently? (Fill in)
    I - Impossible becomes possible What couldn’t be done before? (Fill in)
    F - Forecast anchoring Are they anchoring to current behavior? (Fill in)
    T - Technology cost trajectory What happens at 10x cheaper in 5 years? (Fill in)
  3. Reframe the Proposal (10 minutes):

    • Original framing (technology-first): “We should add [IoT technology]…”
    • Reframed (outcome-first): “Our [customers/users] face [$X cost/Y pain], competitors will soon offer this, we can create [3 new revenue streams]…”

Deliverables:

  • Completed SHIFT analysis table
  • Side-by-side comparison: original technology-first framing vs. reframed value-first framing
  • One-paragraph competitive threat assessment: “What happens if our competitor does this first?”

Success Criteria:

  • You identify at least 2 second-order effects that weren’t in the original proposal
  • Your reframing quantifies financial impact ($X savings, $Y revenue, Z% reduction)
  • You name specific competitors or adjacent industries that might enter your space

Example Output:

Original Proposal: “Add GPS trackers to our rental construction equipment.”

Leadership Objection: “Equipment theft is rare. This is a solution looking for a problem.”

SHIFT Analysis: For “- S - Second-order: Theft prevention → utilization tracking → identifying underused as”: label the rental-equipment fleet sizes, utilization, revenue and savings as hypothetical exercise inputs; state how to measure each in a real pilot. - H - Behavior: Customers stop hoarding equipment “just in case” → better utilization across all customers → we serve more customers with same fleet - I - Impossible: No visibility into equipment usage patterns → now can optimize maintenance schedules → prevent breakdowns proactively For “- F - Anchoring: Yes - leadership anchors to”low theft rate” and misses 15-20% of fle”: label the rental-equipment fleet sizes, utilization, revenue and savings as hypothetical exercise inputs; state how to measure each in a real pilot. - T - Cost: $50/device today → $5/device in 5 years → embed in EVERY tool, not just expensive equipment

For “Reframed Proposal:”15-20% of our $50M fleet sits idle while customers request equipment”: label the rental-equipment fleet sizes, utilization, revenue and savings as hypothetical exercise inputs; state how to measure each in a real pilot. GPS tracking enables usage-based pricing ($8K/year per unit revenue vs. For “$3K/year flat rental), predictive maintenance (40% reduction in breakdowns), and theft rec”: label the rental-equipment fleet sizes, utilization, revenue and savings as hypothetical exercise inputs; state how to measure each in a real pilot. Competitors United Rentals and Sunbelt already offer this. ROI: 8.2 months.”

Reflection Questions:

  1. Which of the 5 cognitive mechanisms (anchoring, linear thinking, old metrics, second-order effects, survivorship bias) was strongest in your leadership’s dismissal?
  2. If you had to pick ONE element of the SHIFT framework that’s most compelling for your organization, which would it be?
  3. What parallel from history (telephone, mobile, Internet, smart watches) resonates most for your industry?

Back to the chapter