Detect Paradigm Blindness
Detect Paradigm Blindness
Detect Paradigm Blindness
Time: 45 minutes | Difficulty: Intermediate | Challenge: Apply the SHIFT framework to an IoT proposal in your environment
Scenario: Identify ONE IoT application in your industry or organization that leadership has dismissed as “unnecessary” or “too expensive.” Use the SHIFT framework to reframe the proposal.
Your Task:
Document the Dismissal (5 minutes):
- What was the IoT proposal? (sensors in X, connected Y, automated Z)
- What objection did leadership raise? (customers don’t ask for it, too expensive, not our core business, etc.)
- Which historical parallel does this match? (messenger boys, mobile phones, smart watches)
Apply SHIFT Framework (30 minutes):
Letter Question Your Analysis S - Second-order effects What happens AFTER the first use case? (Fill in) H - Human behavior change How might people behave differently? (Fill in) I - Impossible becomes possible What couldn’t be done before? (Fill in) F - Forecast anchoring Are they anchoring to current behavior? (Fill in) T - Technology cost trajectory What happens at 10x cheaper in 5 years? (Fill in) Reframe the Proposal (10 minutes):
- Original framing (technology-first): “We should add [IoT technology]…”
- Reframed (outcome-first): “Our [customers/users] face [$X cost/Y pain], competitors will soon offer this, we can create [3 new revenue streams]…”
Deliverables:
- Completed SHIFT analysis table
- Side-by-side comparison: original technology-first framing vs. reframed value-first framing
- One-paragraph competitive threat assessment: “What happens if our competitor does this first?”
Success Criteria:
- You identify at least 2 second-order effects that weren’t in the original proposal
- Your reframing quantifies financial impact ($X savings, $Y revenue, Z% reduction)
- You name specific competitors or adjacent industries that might enter your space
Example Output:
Original Proposal: “Add GPS trackers to our rental construction equipment.”
Leadership Objection: “Equipment theft is rare. This is a solution looking for a problem.”
SHIFT Analysis: For “- S - Second-order: Theft prevention → utilization tracking → identifying underused as”: label the rental-equipment fleet sizes, utilization, revenue and savings as hypothetical exercise inputs; state how to measure each in a real pilot. - H - Behavior: Customers stop hoarding equipment “just in case” → better utilization across all customers → we serve more customers with same fleet - I - Impossible: No visibility into equipment usage patterns → now can optimize maintenance schedules → prevent breakdowns proactively For “- F - Anchoring: Yes - leadership anchors to”low theft rate” and misses 15-20% of fle”: label the rental-equipment fleet sizes, utilization, revenue and savings as hypothetical exercise inputs; state how to measure each in a real pilot. - T - Cost: $50/device today → $5/device in 5 years → embed in EVERY tool, not just expensive equipment
For “Reframed Proposal:”15-20% of our $50M fleet sits idle while customers request equipment”: label the rental-equipment fleet sizes, utilization, revenue and savings as hypothetical exercise inputs; state how to measure each in a real pilot. GPS tracking enables usage-based pricing ($8K/year per unit revenue vs. For “$3K/year flat rental), predictive maintenance (40% reduction in breakdowns), and theft rec”: label the rental-equipment fleet sizes, utilization, revenue and savings as hypothetical exercise inputs; state how to measure each in a real pilot. Competitors United Rentals and Sunbelt already offer this. ROI: 8.2 months.”
Reflection Questions:
- Which of the 5 cognitive mechanisms (anchoring, linear thinking, old metrics, second-order effects, survivorship bias) was strongest in your leadership’s dismissal?
- If you had to pick ONE element of the SHIFT framework that’s most compelling for your organization, which would it be?
- What parallel from history (telephone, mobile, Internet, smart watches) resonates most for your industry?